Hedonic vs. Eudaimonic Happiness: What’s the Difference?

When we talk about happiness, it’s easy to imagine a spectrum ranging from momentary pleasures to profound life satisfaction. Indeed, well-being research has uncovered various happiness theories, each providing a unique definition and perspective on what constitutes happiness. However, in the world of happiness psychology, two primary types of happiness are often discussed—hedonic vs. eudaimonic happiness. This distinction offers a deeper understanding of how we experience and sustain joy and fulfillment in our lives. 

The hedonic vs. eudaimonic happiness theory, rooted in philosophical theory, helps us explore how pleasure and meaning contribute to our overall well-being. Researchers Ryan and Deci took the philosophical view on hedonic vs. eudaimonic happiness to the next level through scientific research. They distinguish between hedonic well-being, which focuses on happiness and pleasure, and eudaimonic well-being, which emphasizes meaning and self-realization. 

Both forms of happiness play a role in our lives, but understanding their differences can help us make more conscious choices in pursuit of a meaningful life.

Hedonic vs. Eudaimonic Happiness Definition

To truly grasp the difference between eudaimonic and hedonic happiness, it’s crucial to define each term.

Hedonic Happiness Definition: Hedonic happiness is rooted in the pursuit of pleasure and the avoidance of pain. This form of happiness is about maximizing positive emotions and minimizing negative ones. It’s often associated with sensory pleasures, material gains, and activities that bring immediate gratification—such as eating a delicious meal, enjoying a leisurely vacation, or buying something new. The core idea of hedonism vs. eudaimonia lies in seeking pleasure for its own sake, focusing on experiences that provide short-term joy and satisfaction.

Eudaimonic Well-Being Definition: In contrast, eudaimonic happiness is about finding meaning, purpose, and personal growth. Derived from the Greek word “eudaimonia,” which means “human flourishing,” this form of happiness emphasizes living in alignment with one’s values and striving toward self-actualization. Eudaimonia and happiness are connected through a deeper sense of fulfillment that comes from contributing to something larger than oneself, cultivating personal strengths, and pursuing goals that resonate with one’s true self. It goes beyond fleeting pleasures to encompass a meaningful life and a sense of purpose. Therefore, eudaimonic happiness is sometimes referred to as “meaningful life happiness”.

Hedonic vs. Eudaimonic Happiness: The Key Differences

The difference between eudaimonic and hedonic happiness lies primarily in their sources and sustainability. However, let’s dive deeper into the key differences between hedonism vs. eudaimonia. 

• Source of Happiness: Hedonic happiness is externally driven and focuses on immediate gratification. It seeks to maximize pleasure through activities that provide short-term enjoyment. Eudaimonic happiness, however, is internally driven and arises from living in accordance with one’s values, pursuing meaningful goals, and developing personal strengths.
• Sustainability: Hedonic happiness can be fleeting, as it relies on external circumstances that are often temporary. Once the pleasurable experience fades, so does the happiness it brought. In contrast, eudaimonic happiness is more enduring because it stems from internal growth, purpose, and a sense of accomplishment. It provides a more stable and deep happiness that is less dependent on external factors.
• Emotional Impact: Hedonic pursuits can lead to a cycle of seeking more pleasure, sometimes resulting in a “hedonic treadmill,” where one continually chases happiness without achieving lasting fulfillment. Eudaimonic pursuits, on the other hand, foster positive emotions like contentment, resilience, and gratitude, which contribute to overall well-being.

How to Achieve Hedonic Happiness

While hedonic happiness may not provide lasting fulfillment, it’s still an important aspect of life. Here’s how to achieve it in a balanced way:

1. Engage in Enjoyable Activities: Allocate time for activities that bring you joy, whether it’s indulging in a favorite hobby, enjoying good food, or spending time with loved ones. The key is to savor these moments fully, without overindulgence.
2. Practice Self-Care: Take care of your physical and emotional well-being by ensuring adequate rest, relaxation, and pampering. Hedonic happiness can be nurtured through simple pleasures like a warm bath, a relaxing massage, or a leisurely walk in nature.
3. Experience Sensory Pleasures: Engage your senses by appreciating beauty in the world around you. Listen to your favorite music, watch a beautiful sunset, or enjoy the taste of a delicious meal. These experiences can provide temporary boosts of happiness.
4. Celebrate Small Wins: Acknowledge and celebrate your achievements, no matter how small. This can bring a sense of joy and pleasure, enhancing your hedonic well-being.

How to Make the Most of Hedonic Happiness?

While hedonic happiness is valuable for short-term joy, maximizing its impact involves mindful techniques that allow us to savor, anticipate, and reminisce positive experiences. Here are three powerful strategies to make the most of hedonic happiness:

Anticipatory Savoring

• The anticipation of a pleasurable event, like a vacation, a massage, or a special meal, can boost your mood even before the event takes place. By leaning into this feeling of excitement, you can extend the joy associated with the experience.
• To practice anticipatory savoring, imagine the upcoming experience in broad strokes, focusing on the positive emotions it might evoke. However, avoid over-glorifying the event with too much detail. Sometimes, people create unrealistic expectations that can lead to disappointment if the reality doesn’t match their idealized vision. Keep your expectations high enough to motivate and inspire you but grounded in reality.
• For goals or achievements, high expectations can enhance your creativity, productivity, and problem-solving abilities. Visualizing a positive outcome can motivate you to put in the effort needed to achieve success, which, in turn, enhances hedonic well-being.

Savoring the Moment

• When experiencing a pleasurable moment, such as a meal with loved ones or a beautiful sunset, make a conscious effort to be present. Practice mindfulness by focusing on your senses and the emotions you’re feeling. Avoid distractions that pull you away from the experience, like thoughts about work or upcoming tasks.
• Savoring is about stepping outside of the experience to appreciate and enhance it. By truly attending to and immersing yourself in the moment, you amplify its positive effect and prevent hedonic adaptation—the tendency to quickly return to a baseline level of happiness.
• Use techniques like deep breathing, slowing down, and connecting with your surroundings. For instance, if you’re on vacation, take a moment to observe the beauty around you, feel the warmth of the sun, and listen to the sounds of nature. Sharing these moments with others can also enhance savoring, as social interactions can intensify the pleasure of the experience.

Reminiscing

• Reflecting on positive experiences from the past can evoke a sense of warmth and joy, raising your current positive emotions. Reminiscing can be a powerful way to relive the happiness you once felt, reinforcing the memory and its positive impact on your mood.
• Spend time recalling joyful events, such as a favorite trip, a special celebration, or an accomplishment that made you proud. Engage in activities that help you reminisce, like looking at photos, sharing stories with loved ones, or writing in a gratitude journal.
• While reminiscing, focus on the emotions you experienced, the sensory details, and the meaningful aspects of the event. This process not only boosts hedonic well-being in the present but also strengthens your ability to savor future experiences.

By incorporating these techniques, you can make the most of hedonic happiness in a balanced way. While it’s essential to enjoy life’s pleasures, integrating these mindful practices can enhance the overall impact of hedonic happiness in your life.

How to Achieve Eudaimonic Happiness

While hedonic happiness is valuable for short-term joy, it’s important to balance these pleasures with activities that promote eudaimonic happiness for deeper, lasting fulfillment.

Eudaimonic happiness requires a more intentional and reflective approach to life. Here are ways to cultivate it:

1. Pursue Personal Growth: Engage in activities that challenge you to grow and develop. This could include learning new skills, pursuing higher education, or engaging in self-reflection to better understand yourself. Growth leads to a sense of accomplishment and fulfillment.
2. Find Meaning and Purpose: Identify what gives your life meaning. This could involve contributing to a cause you care about, engaging in meaningful work, or fostering deep connections with others. When your actions align with your values, you experience a profound sense of eudaimonia and happiness.
3. Cultivate Relationships: Build and nurture relationships that provide emotional support, love, and connection. Engaging in acts of kindness, empathy, and compassion towards others fosters a sense of purpose and belonging.
4. Use Your Strengths: Recognize your unique strengths and talents, and use them to make a positive impact. When you utilize your strengths in service to others or in pursuit of your goals, you experience a deeper sense of fulfillment and satisfaction.
5. Set and Pursue Meaningful Goals: Identify long-term goals that resonate with your core values and work towards them. The process of striving for these goals and the sense of purpose they provide contributes to lasting eudaimonic happiness.

Why Eudaimonic Happiness is More Sustainable

While hedonic happiness offers immediate pleasure, it often leads to a cycle of continually seeking more without achieving lasting contentment. This is known as the “hedonic treadmill,” where the pursuit of pleasure becomes an endless chase, and the joy derived from these experiences diminishes over time. In contrast, eudaimonic happiness is more sustainable because it is rooted in deeper, intrinsic values. It fosters personal growth, self-acceptance, and a sense of accomplishment, which contribute to stable and deep happiness.

Eudaimonia and happiness are interlinked through a life lived in alignment with one’s values and purpose. When you pursue eudaimonic well-being, you experience a more profound sense of life satisfaction that doesn’t waver with external circumstances. Research suggests that those who focus on eudaimonic pursuits tend to have better physical health, stronger relationships, and a greater sense of resilience.

By cultivating eudaimonic happiness, you build a foundation for lasting well-being. It encourages you to seek meaning, connect with others, and grow as a person. While hedonic happiness is essential for enjoying life’s pleasures, it’s the pursuit of eudaimonia that leads to a more fulfilling and meaningful life. Therefore, in the balance of hedonic vs. eudaimonic happiness, eudaimonic happiness emerges as the more sustainable path to long-term fulfillment.

Conclusion

Understanding the difference between hedonic vs. eudaimonic happiness allows us to make conscious choices in our pursuit of well-being. While hedonic happiness provides short-term pleasure, eudaimonic happiness offers a more sustainable path to a fulfilling life by emphasizing meaning, personal growth, and purpose. Striking a balance between these two types of happiness can lead to a richer, more rewarding experience.

At 4HappyU, we believe in fostering eudaimonic well-being through our services, including coaching, positive psychotherapy, and therapy for breaking free from limiting beliefs. To explore how we can support your journey toward a more meaningful and happy life, visit our website to book a session.

Resources

The information in this article is grounded in scientific research. If you’re interested in specific studies, feel free to reach out to us.

For daily doses of joy, positivity, inspiration, and motivation, be sure to follow us on Instagram.